header
Home Page
About the Tech-Writer
Technical Writing Articles Graphics, Art, and Photography pens tab
Visit Our Online Store

Fountain Pens > Pen Notes >

Pen Condition Rating Scale

Is it in working order?  Will the pen perform as normally expected with the writing components in good working order.

Why is condition important?  A pen's condition largely determines its attractiveness to collectors and its price. Condition is very important. 

The description of each pen for sale contains a condition grade (for example B/1m or A2/1b). This describes both the pen and the nib


Pen Grade


A1 - Mint (uninked): Shows no signs of use - possibly new old stock - mainly modern limited editions

A2 - Unused (Inked): Shows no sign of use other than having been dipped or filled with ink - this is usually the top condition grade possible for vintage pens as we test the filling system and the nib as part of the service

B - Excellent:
All parts original and showing only very slight signs of use: slight surface scratching; very minor discoloration or brassing; crisp imprints; no significant dings. 
Most of our vintage pens fall into this category as being excellent, collectible examples which are also suitable for everyday use

C - Fine: All parts original: some discoloration and brassing; light or worn imprints; small dings to metal or scratching on plastic.  Unless very rare, we would not normally advertise a pen in this grade.
A combination of discoloration and brassing, possibly a worn imprint or maybe other degradation of the material means that pens in this condition are seldom desirable

D - Fair: Some parts possibly not original; significant brassing/discoloration; very worn imprints; dings and scratches. Maybe a good writing pen or probably one to consign to the part bins!

Many pens (e.g., a Parker Duofold in mandarin yellow) might be excellent everyday writing pens even with a hairline crack - but a description of the defect should be included in the overall rating


Nib Grade


Nib Grade and Style:
f - Fine
m - Medium
b - broad
s - Stub
obl - Oblique
Flexible
Rigid

Nib condition - is it okay for daily writing?

1 - Nib is  in excellent condition with no damage to tines or iridium
2 - Nib is useable with no damage to tines, some use evident on iridium
3 - Nib is useable but with some distortion to tines or significant iridium wear
4 - Nib  has damaged tines or damaged iridium or hairline crack - can be repaired
5 - Nib is damaged beyond repair or is not useable

Note whether the nib is 'correct' for the pen


Additional Comments

This will include details of:
· Any engraving: the initials or text of the engraving are given, e.g., ‘STG’ or ‘Presented to Adam Smith, Jan 1919’.
· Degree of oxidation on hard rubber pens
· Any specific damage, hairline cap lip splits etc.


Combined Grade

For example:
A1/1b [Engraved ‘ADS’ on barrel]
would mean a mint, uninked pen with an excellent, broad nib which has the initials ‘ADS’ engraved on its barrel

B/1f would indicate a pen which has been used but is in good collectible condition and which is fitted with a fine grade nib in excellent shape


Copyright © 1997-2005 Battersea Pen Home (Simon Gray and Sean Lovell). Included here with permission.
http://www.penhome.co.uk/Staticpages/bphconditionscale.htm

pdf Pen Condition Rating Scale 24 KB


back




homeaboutarticlesgraphicspensstore

Copyright © 2003-2007 All Rights Reserved
site design by C-Eye
Search Tech-Writer.net
Buy fountain pen books at the
Tech-Writer.net Online Store.